Policing Board Faces Scrutiny Over PSNI Controversies – Chairman Warns


The Policing Board in Northern Ireland finds itself under the spotlight as it braces to answer questions regarding a series of controversies plaguing the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI). Simon Hoare, chairman of a Westminster committee, has unequivocally stated that the board will be called upon to provide answers before Members of Parliament.

Challenges for the New PSNI Chief Constable

Simon Hoare also acknowledged the daunting nature of the role of the PSNI chief constable, particularly in the wake of the resignation of Simon Byrne. The position, he noted, could be described as the “most difficult gig” in policing.

Mr. Byrne’s resignation, which was made public on Monday, comes on the heels of a string of controversies that have rocked the PSNI. These include a significant data breach that exposed personal details of officers and staff, and a critical High Court ruling deeming the disciplining of two officers involved in an arrest at a Troubles memorial event in Belfast in 2021 as unlawful.

Board Withdraws from Hearing

The committee had been in the process of investigating the data breach, and representatives from the Policing Board, the overseeing body for the PSNI, were scheduled to appear before MPs on Tuesday. However, in the aftermath of Mr. Byrne’s resignation, the board opted to withdraw from the hearing.

Furthermore, a public session of the board that had been slated for Thursday has been canceled, raising concerns among MPs about the scrutiny of recent events.

MP Claire Hanna Expresses Concerns

During the committee’s session, SDLP MP Claire Hanna voiced her concerns, saying, “Could I put on record my concerns that the Policing Board aren’t here? I appreciate it is a choppy time, there is a lot going on, but my understanding is there hasn’t been a meeting in public since the data breach. The one that was scheduled for later this week isn’t occurring. I think it would have been useful and appropriate to have the Policing Board here as part of this session and as part of our scrutiny and as a part of people feeling that these issues are being properly scrutinized.”

Committee Chairman’s Response

In response, Mr. Hoare assured that the Policing Board would be called upon to address the committee’s questions, either voluntarily or through a summons if necessary. He emphasized that they would be expected to do so in public.

Mr. Hoare also paid tribute to anyone taking on the role of chief constable of the PSNI, acknowledging it as one of the most challenging positions in policing. He expressed gratitude to those who stepped up to shape a modern police service amid the current circumstances.

PSNI Chief Constable’s Challenges

Simon Byrne faced a series of challenges in the weeks leading up to his resignation, including the fallout from a major PSNI data breach, where the names and details of all officers and staff members were mistakenly released online. His difficulties compounded when High Court Judge Mr. Justice Scoffield ruled that two junior officers had been unlawfully disciplined for an arrest made at a Troubles commemoration event in 2021. The judge stated that this discipline had been carried out to allay a threat that Sinn Fein could withdraw its support for policing, a claim denied by Sinn Fein.


As the dust settles around the PSNI controversies and the resignation of Chief Constable Simon Byrne, the Policing Board faces a summons to answer questions from MPs. The scrutiny surrounding the PSNI’s recent challenges underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in policing matters.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *